Skip to main content

Table 4 ANOVA results for taxonomic rank “order”. Tukey’s multiple comparison test results after 5000 replications significant p-values (α = 0.01) were averaged and counted for Tukey’s groups (Boston-New York-Sacramento). In general terms, when comparing two cities if letters (‘a’, ‘b’ and ‘c’) are all the same, we conclude that the means are not significantly different. If the letters are different we conclude city means are significantly different in terms of bacterial abundances. As for example, “order” enterobacteriales, shows minimum, average and maximum p-value out of 5000 replications, and 4967 times out of 5000 replications the three city means were found to be significantly different ‘a’-‘b’-‘c‘; 30 times Boston and New York mean bacterial abundances remain the same but Sacramento is different (‘a’-‘a’-‘b’) and only in 3 cases Boston, and Sacramento are the same but New-York (‘a’-‘b’-‘a’) is different deemed by Tukey’s multiple comparison test. Taxonomic rank names (“order”) are presented in the same order for all groups (‘a’-‘b’-‘c’, ‘a’-‘a’-‘b’, ‘a’-‘b’-‘b’, ‘a’-‘b’-‘a’)

From: Unraveling bacterial fingerprints of city subways from microbiome 16S gene profiles

Order

p-value [min, mean, max]

Count

Tukey’s group

Enterobacteriales

[8.45E-17, 3.08E-8, 1.46E-5]

4967

a-b-c

Clostridiales

[1.75E-30, 2.42E-19, 3.13E-16]

4802

Rhizobiales

[5.18E-16, 3.37E-6, 3.25E-4]

4693

Pseudomonadales

[5.37E-15, 6.63E-6, 1.27E-3]

4432

Xanthomonadales

[1.14E-16, 2.01E-11, 3.38E-9]

3134

Flavobacteriales

[1.24E-20, 1.46E-14, 7.18E-12]

1939

Vibrionales

[4.51E-19, 2.3E-13, 1.89E-11]

1939

Sphingobacteriales

[8.56E-16, 1.41E-11, 1.7E-9]

1889

Bacillales

[5.03E-19, 9.78E-14, 1.99E-11]

1562

Alteromonadales

[8.15E-23, 1.22E-16, 4.13E-14]

1478

Bacteroidales

[1.09E-26, 5.25E-18, 4.08E-15]

1474

Rhodobacterales

[9.85E-8, 2.91E-4, 4.53E-3]

1332

Pasteurellales

[2.74E-18, 1.04E-12, 2.15E-10]

1187

Rickettsiales

[4.03E-9, 7.4E-4, 5.75E-3]

683

Lactobacillales

[4.54E-27, 2.6E-17, 5.45E-15]

667

Actinomycetales

[1.9E-7, 8.94E-4, 4.56E-3]

157

Burkholderiales

[6.92E-8, 1.26E-3, 5.4E-3]

95

Sphingomonadales

[1.76E-8, 9.08E-4, 3.62E-3]

43

Rhodospirillales

[2.34E-6, 6.66E-4, 2.78E-3]

24

Enterobacteriales

[6.64E-11, 6.3E-7, 8.58E-6]

30

a-a-b

Clostridiales

[2.6E-24, 6.04E-19, 3.07E-17]

198

Rhizobiales

[3.29E-8, 8.12E-5, 1.8E-3]

288

Pseudomonadales

[2.58E-8, 9.45E-5, 2.22E-3]

187

Xanthomonadales

[6.43E-17, 4.36E-11, 4.84E-9]

1866

Flavobacteriales

[4.06E-21, 4.38E-14, 7.69E-12]

3061

Vibrionales

[4.48E-20, 5.02E-13, 7.33E-11]

3061

Sphingobacteriales

[1.01E-16, 4.25E-11, 3.17E-8]

3111

Bacillales

[6.69E-20, 1.19E-13, 9.96E-11]

3438

Alteromonadales

[1.87E-24, 3.04E-16, 7.47E-14]

3522

Bacteroidales

[7.59E-28, 1.91E-17, 2.23E-14]

3526

Rhodobacterales

[6.23E-8, 9.45E-4, 9.91E-3]

3249

Pasteurellales

[3.69E-19, 2.08E-12, 3.97E-10]

3813

Rickettsiales

[3.36E-7, 4.13E-3, 9.96E-3]

1234

Lactobacillales

[1.14E-25, 1.13E-16, 6.48E-14]

4333

Actinomycetales

[1.01E-5, 4.01E-3, 9.95E-3]

1028

Burkholderiales

[2.04E-5, 4.94E-3, 9.74E-3]

110

Sphingomonadales

  

Rhodospirillales

[4.49E-4, 5.1E-3, 9.91E-3]

57

Enterobacteriales

  

a-b-b

Clostridiales

  

Rhizobiales

[4.35E-9, 4.86E-5, 4.36E-4]

19

Pseudomonadales

  

Xanthomonadales

  

Flavobacteriales

  

Vibrionales

  

Sphingobacteriales

  

Bacillales

  

Alteromonadales

  

Bacteroidales

  

Rhodobacterales

  

Pasteurellales

  

Rickettsiales

[3.84E-7, 2.83E-3, 9.99E-3]

568

Lactobacillales

  

Actinomycetales

[1.18E-5, 2.72E-3, 9.32E-3]

61

Burkholderiales

[6.45E-9, 2.92E-3, 10E-3]

1584

Sphingomonadales

[1.63E-5, 3.33E-3, 9.99E-3]

209

Rhodospirillales

[5.42E-3, 7.22E-3, 10E-3]

5

Enterobacteriales

[6.46E-11, 6.52E-9, 1.94E-8]

3

a-b-a

Clostridiales

  

Rhizobiales

  

Pseudomonadales

[1.38E-12, 5.01E-6, 4.48E-4]

381

Xanthomonadales

  

Flavobacteriales

  

Vibrionales

  

Sphingobacteriales

  

Bacillales

  

Alteromonadales

  

Bacteroidales

  

Rhodobacterales

[9.6E-8, 1.02E-3, 9.81E-3]

320

Pasteurellales

  

Rickettsiales

[3.52E-4, 4.95E-3, 8.88E-3]

27

Lactobacillales

  

Actinomycetales

[1.01E-5, 3.83E-3, 9.88E-3]

261

Burkholderiales

[6.81E-3, 6.81E-3, 6.81E-3]

1

Sphingomonadales

[7.24E-5, 4.92E-3, 9.75E-3]

62

Rhodospirillales

[1.43E-6, 4.15E-3, 9.97E-3]

559